# Q&D Scale Speed Estimates

Discussion in 'FAQs' started by billk, Mar 8, 2002.

1. ### billkActive Member

Joined:
Jun 13, 2001
Messages:
1,130
0
Here's a way to do quick and dirty estimates of your trains speed:

- Pick one of the times from the "seconds" column for your scale
- Measure (or estimate) how far your train goes, in inches, in that amount of time
- Divide that distance by the number at the bottom of the column.

The result is pretty close to the train's speed in MPH. The error for each of the combinations is shown. Once you find a combination that works for you (some of the times are pretty long), you just need to remember the time and the "divide by" number and you can do the math in you head (well, maybe).
2. ### rockislandmikeActive Member

Joined:
Nov 6, 2001
Messages:
1,260
0
Huh, pretty kewl. I'm sort of a math whiz, so I think I prefer the old calculator method (well, actually, I've set up a quick spreadsheet to calculate scale speed), but still a pretty handy table to have. I clocked one of my fave engines at 9mph last night on my shelf layout from end to end.
3. ### sumpter250multiscale modelbuilder

Joined:
Jan 19, 2002
Messages:
3,110
0
Arithmatic gives me a headache, but here goes.

60 MPH, is 88 feet/second
30 MPH, is 44 feet/second
15 MPH, is 22 feet/second...... Yeah, it's linear.
so,
in any scale; 60MPH is two "40' " boxcars/second
30MPH is one "40' " boxcar/second
15MPH is one "40' " boxcar/every 2 seconds

I guess that makes 500MPH faster than a speeding bullet.............train.
4. ### roryglasgowActive Member

Joined:
Jun 4, 2001
Messages:
1,237
0
I once clocked a 2-8-0 Consolidation at 120 MPH on level track!

Of course, that was my old Bachmann...

-Rory
5. ### kettlestackMember

Joined:
Jan 18, 2002
Messages:
866
0
Thanks for the table Bill. I tried several of my HO locos using it.

Results without pulse power:-

3 truck Shay (Bachman) .... 3.2 mph
GP9 (Atheran) ................... 3.0 mph
SW1500 (Athern)............... 3.0 mph
44 tonner (Bachman) ....... 3.0 mph
B30-7 (Bachman) ............. 3.0 mph
4-4-0 "1870's" (IHC) ........ 3.5 mph
2-6-0 Camelback (IHC) .... 3.5 mph
2-8-0 (Bachman) .............. 3.5 mph

Back in '75 I built the TAT IV throttle which has start pulse and variable pulse power. I have yet to test the slow running using this throttle but using it on my N gauge locos I achieved something like 0.2 mph. Of course I wouldn't run locos continually on pulse power. I've heard too much about ruining motors with pulse power although it hasn't happened to me yet.

Errol

Joined:
Jan 1, 2002
Messages:
14