Hello All
I have been a huge Titanic fan since the age of 6 or 7, even before Dr. Rob Ballard found and later explored the wreck I was fascinated with the story and the ship itself. At the age of 7 I bought and built the Taschen 1:200 Titanic (It was a foot longer than I was tall at the time
There was another book, cannot recall the publisher, but it had 3 models in that book, one half model, with the inside visible as in the 1912 White Star Brochure, a second model of the Bow Wreck and a third of the Stern raised into the air, her final plunge.
I live 20 mins from Cobh which was named Queenstown in 1912 when the last passengers were ferried out to the Titanic and I often go there on Sunday mornings for breakfast with friends right across the road from what was the
White Star Lines Offices where those unfortunate passengers left. It beacme a successful restaraunt/bar/cafe in the late 90's but closed soon before I came back from NYC. Ill get some pics this weekend of it. My sister lives now in
Crosshaven, overlooking the last place Titanic dropped anchor just outside the Port of Cork
Anyway, the reason for this thread...I have read and reserched a lot and intend one day to build a model of the Titanic but I would like to bounce a few questions out there for discussion. I know of the TRMA but their wesbite is full
of tangled web postings (the layout is confusing and it is an annoying chore to follow a thread) and with respect the majority of members, I have encountered a few weirdo's and been on the recieving end of a few too brutal posted responses
when questioning things..( my personal favourite was the "any 1st year Titanic Student would have known that!!!!!")
I enjoy the Titanic as a subject, I love Models but I dont do not let it get to that kind of level... Im not a rivet counter but I do appreciate accuracy so I am hoping that the wealth of information I have seen being shared on the Titanic
build threads here in Cardmodels.net might be available here too in a condesnsed format and hopefully without the attitude..
So I am going to kick it off....
My two favourite references are The Fly-Model/ Gomix Titanic & the Peter Garner-Davies Titanic:
I picked up the PDG Model Book a few years ago, A book shop had it on a bargain table 2 weeks after the official release, I picked it up immediately and thinks it's a great tool for anyone building any model ship, not just the Titanic... I
think it is a stunning model and would love to have seen it when I was at the Titanic: The Exhibition in Florida but by that time they had sold it on to another exhibition. To me one of the most important things in that book is the
over all hull and shell plating lines. I have the Hahn 1:100 plans too but feel that the PDG ones, though smaller are a bit more managible, plus the Hahn ones do not have the wing Propellor positions marked out at all. L
Does anyone here have an opinion on the two for a better hull shape? By better I would mean what is generally accepted as closer to the original in shape and details of shell plating.
I was delighted to see that Gomix were offering the 1:200 Titanic. I had just finished up their 1:100 Kursk and was quite impressed with the fit and quality of printing with that kit and held out high hopes for the Titanic. Unfortunately
as many of you might agree the colours selected and used as well as general look of the kit is comical...well to me anyway they are and that has given me enough reason to not build it. However I do find that the overall shape and patterns
are very well done, as well as the amount of little details that seem to match the PDG model.
Does anyone else have these two and have you been able to compare them? I want to get a nice hull shape and plating lines how do each of them fair?
So that's how I will start, any opinion is 100% welcome and appreciated
Thanks all for your time
John John
I have been a huge Titanic fan since the age of 6 or 7, even before Dr. Rob Ballard found and later explored the wreck I was fascinated with the story and the ship itself. At the age of 7 I bought and built the Taschen 1:200 Titanic (It was a foot longer than I was tall at the time

I live 20 mins from Cobh which was named Queenstown in 1912 when the last passengers were ferried out to the Titanic and I often go there on Sunday mornings for breakfast with friends right across the road from what was the
White Star Lines Offices where those unfortunate passengers left. It beacme a successful restaraunt/bar/cafe in the late 90's but closed soon before I came back from NYC. Ill get some pics this weekend of it. My sister lives now in
Crosshaven, overlooking the last place Titanic dropped anchor just outside the Port of Cork
Anyway, the reason for this thread...I have read and reserched a lot and intend one day to build a model of the Titanic but I would like to bounce a few questions out there for discussion. I know of the TRMA but their wesbite is full
of tangled web postings (the layout is confusing and it is an annoying chore to follow a thread) and with respect the majority of members, I have encountered a few weirdo's and been on the recieving end of a few too brutal posted responses
when questioning things..( my personal favourite was the "any 1st year Titanic Student would have known that!!!!!")
I enjoy the Titanic as a subject, I love Models but I dont do not let it get to that kind of level... Im not a rivet counter but I do appreciate accuracy so I am hoping that the wealth of information I have seen being shared on the Titanic
build threads here in Cardmodels.net might be available here too in a condesnsed format and hopefully without the attitude..
So I am going to kick it off....
My two favourite references are The Fly-Model/ Gomix Titanic & the Peter Garner-Davies Titanic:
I picked up the PDG Model Book a few years ago, A book shop had it on a bargain table 2 weeks after the official release, I picked it up immediately and thinks it's a great tool for anyone building any model ship, not just the Titanic... I
think it is a stunning model and would love to have seen it when I was at the Titanic: The Exhibition in Florida but by that time they had sold it on to another exhibition. To me one of the most important things in that book is the
over all hull and shell plating lines. I have the Hahn 1:100 plans too but feel that the PDG ones, though smaller are a bit more managible, plus the Hahn ones do not have the wing Propellor positions marked out at all. L
Does anyone here have an opinion on the two for a better hull shape? By better I would mean what is generally accepted as closer to the original in shape and details of shell plating.
I was delighted to see that Gomix were offering the 1:200 Titanic. I had just finished up their 1:100 Kursk and was quite impressed with the fit and quality of printing with that kit and held out high hopes for the Titanic. Unfortunately
as many of you might agree the colours selected and used as well as general look of the kit is comical...well to me anyway they are and that has given me enough reason to not build it. However I do find that the overall shape and patterns
are very well done, as well as the amount of little details that seem to match the PDG model.
Does anyone else have these two and have you been able to compare them? I want to get a nice hull shape and plating lines how do each of them fair?
So that's how I will start, any opinion is 100% welcome and appreciated
Thanks all for your time
John John