E-Paw, I think you are the Pennsy expert I have been looking for!
I live on the west coast and have never seen a Pennsy loco in the flesh. I have to paint an I-1 decapod with the long tender and dog house, a T-1, and the S-2. Given the availability of modeler's paint currently out on the market, what choices do I have for the black (is it really green?), the graphite for the smoke box, and the red that is sometimes used on the tops of tenders and loco roof. I do have some colors in Floquil and Scalecoat, but its difficult to find anymore in hobby stores. I have searched a number of websites and have not found painting information, nor have I been able to find any color photos of the actual locos.
There are lots of rumors floating around the west coast regarding the 'green' that most think is 'engine black.' However, I have a factory painted Spectrum K-4 that sure looks black to me.
I am appreciative of any help you can give me, or anyone else out there can give me.
-Ed